Georgetown, New Mexico History and
Cemetery
Compiled by Dorothy M. Wokee of Hanover New Mexico Format by C. W. Barnum Return To History Page Return to Cemetery Index Photos
Georgetown Cemetery Alphabetical List of Interments Analysis & Cemetery Sources Brief History of Georgetown Publications with References to Georgetown Database Analysis The total number of burials in the Georgetown Cemetery according to this list is 114. Of these, 18 are designated by name or initials only and 4 are reserved sites for people still living. There are thirty-eight unmarked sites, as shown on Map by a broken circle, they are not included in this count since they are most likely graves for persons listed here but not identified by plot numbers or names. The remaining 92 for which some information is known, if only name and Date of Death, are categorized as follows: Number buried per year of death One each in 1868, 75, 76, 78, 83, 86, 87, 88, 89,
91, 1900, 12, 17, 19, 20, 21, 23, 25, 33, 34, 36, 39,
45, 46, 61, 62, 77, 79, 94, 95, 97, 98 Two each in 1881, 90, 98, 1911, 14, 16, 18, 22, 27, 28, 29, 32, 40, 42, 43, 48 Total 32 Four each in 1877 Total 4 Five each in 1880 and 1915 Total 10 Six each in 1879 Total 6 Eight each in 1882 Total 8 None in 1869-74, 84, 85, 92-97, 99 1901 to 1910, 10, 13, 24, 26, 30, 31, 35, 37, 38, 41, 44, 47, 49-60, 63-76, 78, 80-93, 96, 99
References I. Dorothy Wokee for this list: Another attempt at assuaging my guilt has been to compile this list of persons buried, or said to be buried, in the Georgetown Cemetery. While walking through the yard over the years, I made a list of the tombstone names, dates and inscriptions. Learning that local interest was great, I then sought other sources in order to compile a comprehensive record. This is the result of that effort. I would also like to mention that I have included any names which were reported to be buried in Georgetown, although I have been told by some that there may be another location which was considered an extension of the Georgetown Cemetery; specifically, a graveyard located just West of the Georgetown Masonic Lodge in Mimbres. However, a brief survey of that privately owned cemetery, owner-Tony Grijalva, Mimbres, did not reveal any names listed here for Georgetown. As I uncover more information, I will periodically update these lists and the map. The following are some of the resources I used as
well as some which did not add to my data, but were
consulted: These codes show source of record:
Data Sources in order of Priority used: 1. NM death records 1907-22,1927,1937-8 III. SJP - Sister Jean Potter, List is located at Georgetown Masonic Lodge, Mimbres The following is excerpted from the narrative written by Sister Jean Potter:
IV. The Georgetown Cemetery listed by Randy and Linda Isbell V. Headstones in Georgetown Cemetery: VI. Other Contacts:
Consolidated List of Grave Sites J. A., (C13) (SJP) Acosta, Jose(D12) 1851-1914; 63 yrs Alien, William W. (DOS) 05/02/1818-08/09/1883; 70 yrs, 3 mos, 1da "is gone a light from our household a voice we loved is stilled a place is vacant in our hearts that never can be filled" Alvarado, Pedro C.(D11)05/13/1883-06/19/1918; 35yrs,1mo,6da "Su esposa Ie dedica este recuerdo Gregoria & Alvarado" Anthony, Josephine Mary 03/27/1911-10/12/1922; 11yrs, 6mos, 15da (JSL) "Pb.Membres River, f. (William Anthny, b.Geotwn,NM) m. Josephine Sefruad? Armifo, Jose -Sept 1879(JSL) OB-GCH, Jose Ma & Family? Arroyos, Mrs. Juan -Sept 1879(JSL) OB-GCH Backus, Felipe 1865-2/1877; 12 yrs JSL) OB-GCH Barillo, (Stillborn boy) 06/12/1922-06/12/1922 (JSL) b. Gtwn.NM, f. Narcisco m. Rabola Romero, b. NM Bennett, Alexander W. 12/26/1889-03/14/1920; 30 yrs, 2 mos, 18da (JSL) b. Gtwn.NM f. (R.,b.PA); m. Minnie Prevson, b. Tx., w. Nellie R. (List shows G'town Cem, but City "SantaRita") Bennett, Alice (C04) 08/29/1876-04/16/1880;3yrs,7mos,16 da "These lovely birds. So young and fair, Called hence by early doom. Just came to show. How sweet such flowers in paradise could bloom" Bennett, Harriet (C05) 04/06/1879-04/16/1880; 11 mos,6da same obelisk as Maudy and Alice; inscription above on 4th side of obelisk Bennett, Ida May (C02) 03/09/1881-03/18/1882;11 mos, 6 da "Our Darling" (same yard as Maudy, Alice and Harriet, but separate stone) Bennett, Maudy (C03) 04/23/1878-05/10/1878; 17 da same obelisk as Harriet and Alice; inscription on 4th side of obelisk Bennett, Minnie Pretzer. (C22) 09/16/1856-70/15/1946; 90 yrs Located at different site from other Bennetts; just NW of Hightower; SW of Mattocks Bloodgood, little girl-(SJP)cto' of Eunice & Clyde Bloodgood; buried near her grandmother Alice Gumm, adoptive mth of Eunice Bloodgood; information from Agnes Menard, niece-in-law to Alice Gumm Cameron, Emma (B07) 12/11/1871 -11/07/1887;15yrs, 10 mos, 27da "Sacred to the memory of; Beloved Wife of A.S. Cameron" Carson, Mabel G(B06)01/26/1873-04/16/1889;16yrs,2mos,21da "In Memory of (JSL) 03/21/1 873 Caseldine, Harry C. 1882-05/25/1911; 29 yrs (JSL) Pb.Ky, was physician and surgeon; died of TB. (List shows 2 listings, both G'twn Cem; one with "City"-Silver City; the other "City" is Kentucky Castillo, (018) -1868 (JSL)"&" Castillo, Alfredo (D15) 1920-1940; 20 yrs (JSL) & "age 28 years" Castillo, Bonifacio (D14) 06/13/1869-07/05/1939; 70yrs,1 mo,22da New stone says: 1868-1939 (JSL) 5/14/1869 Castillo, Esiquio(D13) 1888-8/27/1927; 39 yrs Pick,shovel and key carved into headstone (JSL) 1st listing 1839-8/20 or 25/1927; (JSL) 2nd listing Costillo.Eignio? 1849-8/28/1927 ? b.Mex., Single Castillo, Juana (D17) 6/24/1875-6/25/1948; 73 yrs, 1 da (JSL) Juanita Torres 6/24/1874. Castillo, Luis A. (D16) 1873-7?/25/1961 (JSL) Castillo, Louis or Lois (D16) Clark, James A. (B08) 10/11/1886-11/10/1888; 2yrs,1mo "Son ofW.E. & K.A. Clark" Cooper, D.C. -05/28/1877 (JSL) OB-GCH? Cordova, Francisca R.(B13) 1876-1912; 36yrs B12,13,14are listed together ona single stone (JSL) (C17) Francisco R. Cordova, Manuel (B11) single oblong limestone; (JSL) E.M., April-DeLaFallecio-Dad, Cordova, Manuel H.(B14) 1888-1936:48 yrs B12,13,14 are listed together on a single stone Cordova, Margarita (B12)2/26/1905-9/75/1943;37yrs,8mos,19da B12,13,14 are listed together on asingle stone (JSL) (C18) Crittendon, James E. (B02) 1897-1915; 18 yrs Crittendon, James H. (B01) 1869-1915; 46yrs Cronin, Thomas -07/30/1880 (JSL) OB-GCH Dempster, -12/31/1881 (JSL) OB-NS died in Gtwn, NM Dominguez, Francisco (DOS) 09/16/1868-07/11/1917; 48yrs, 3 mos, Ida "Que En Paz Descanse" C. E. (D22)(SJP) (JSL) "&" (Uk) Eddleman, Edward V.(A02) 1923-1928; 5 yrs Eddleman, Linda Marie (A01 b) 08/23/1962-08/24/1962; 1 da "Beloved Daughter of the Bill Eddlemans Gone to be an Angel" Eddleman, Mary (A04) 7/22/1896-3/24/1979; 83 yrs, 2 mos, 2 da Nee Mitchell Eddleman, Mosby E.(A03) 1895-1943; 48 yrs "Father" Eddleman, Robert Morris. (A01) 01/17/1929-03/09/1948; 19 yrs, 1 mo, 22 da Eddleman,William R (A01 a)12/24/1934-05/04/1994; 59yrs,4mos,10da "My beloved husband; Loving Father & Grandpa; A cherished friend; We Will Love You Forever" Eidson, John A. (A15) 06/11/1875-08/31/1900; 25yrs,4mos,10da "Son of JW and TE Eidson" Encinias, Luis D. (C07) 1803-02/05/1923; 120 yrs (SJP) Luis Encinas is the father of Maria Montoya-reported by Cecilio Torres of Bayard, NM-a relative. Grave is located in yard with Montoya's; "se fue pero no olivadado" Flores, -09/20/1879 (JSL) OB-GCH, one of two men Fowler, David Ray (A19)06/21/1965-09/06/1995;30yrs,2mo,16da "Loving Son" Fowler, Vernon Ray (A20) 08/16/1939- "Daddy" A.G. (C14) (SJP) Galindo, -06/1879 (JSL) OB-GCH Glascow, Sam -07/08/1882 (JSL) OB-NS (JSL) Judge Sholl List of Grant Co. Death Records 1867-1987 (list is located in Silver City Public Library/Treasure Room) Gomez, Eulogia R (D07) 1856-03/19/1915; 58yrs "Que En Paz Descanse" (JSL) EulogiaD^ & "ue fallecio Marzio 10 de 1915, 58anos" Greer, G. W. -11/1875 JSL) OB-GCH Gumm, Alice (C19) -10/20/1940 (JSL) (SJP) This info. was given by Mrs. Maude Bagwell of Silver City, who stated that Mrs. Gumm Died two days before her mother, verified by John Menard of Hurley, NM-a nephew of Mrs. Gumm Hagan, John A -09/19/1879 (JSL) OB-GCH Harvey, William -04/03/1882 (JSL) OB-NS Heuchling, Otto (A 14) 03/16/1856-03/12/1932; 75 yrs, 11 mos, 24da (JSL) (SJP) This info came from Mrs. Hedgewick Berger of Silver City, NM-also verified from Masonic records in possession of Mason Mattocks of Mimbres, NM. Stone says only "Grandpa Otto" Hightower, Rebecca (C20) 1824-1914; 90 yrs Horciertas, Mrs. L. 1889-06/28/1911 ; 22 yrs (JSL) Died at Santa Rita Howe, Fred -09/03/1882 (JSL) OB-NS Kennedy, (child) 1880-07/1882; 2 yrs (JSL) OB-NS, f. was a Judge Kennedy, Rena Bagess -06/23/1882 (JSL) OB-NS Kester, Silvester J. 1852-02/10/1877; 25 yrs (JSL) OB-GCH Knight, Ed (A07a) (JSL)"&" (SJP) According to Mrs. Gary Dodson Knight, wife (of Ed) (A07b) (JSL)"<S" (SJP) According to Mrs. Gary Dodson Knuckey, Myrtle Emma (C11) 04/13/1898-10/5/1898 (88?), 5mos, 22da (SJP) (JSL) &GE5mos,2Ada Lacy, Jacob M. (A08a) 1825-1891:66 yrs grave site of Jacob M. Lacy; according to his g.grandson Lester Lacy Lae, Jose (C10)(JSL) Lea. (SJP) Ano 11 /78/88"; Headstone hard to read LaFrenz, Marie Voile (A13) 07/30/1865-08/24/1945; 80 yrs, 24 da "Mother" LaFrenz, Robert Ludwig (A12) 17/07/1860-03/76/1934; 73yrs, 4 mos, 15 da "Father" Lucas, Albert (Baby) -07/23/1881 (JSL) OB-NS, /. Jason A. Lucas Luce, J.D. LaLuz (D10) 1871-09/76/1918; 42 yrs "Aqui Vacan Restos;Sus Padre Le dedican este Recuerdo R.I.P." M. (D5) (SJP) A. M. (04)(SJP) (JSL) "&" Uk M. M. (D6) (SJP) Madrid, Feliciano 06/10/1932-08/15/1932; 2 mos, 5 da (JSL) Mattocks, James M. (D21) 02/14/1858-04/15/1933; 75yrs, 2mos, 1da (JSL) (SJP) Mrs. Maude Bagwell stated that Lilly Moore Mattocks and James M. Mattocks were her parents and she gave me the information. James & Lilly were grandparents of Mason & Ena Mattocks (from Ena Osbom/Mattocks, Mimbres, NM) Mattocks, Lilly Moore (020) 08/10/1868-10/22/1942; 74 yrs, 2 mo, 12da (JSL) (SJP) Mrs. Maude Bagwell stated that Lilly Moore Mattocks and James M. Mattocks were her parents and she gave me the information. James & Lilly were grandparents of Mason and Ena Mattocks (from Ena Osborn/Mattocks, Mimbres, NM) Mattocks, Mason Ralph (018)08/28/1922-03/27/1977; 54 yrs, 7 mos, 5da "Tech 5 U.S. Army wwn" Brother of Ena Osborn/Mattocks,Mimbres,NM Mattocks, Ralph (D19) 1888-1942; 54 yrs Father of Mason and Ena Mattocks(from Ena Osborn/Mattocks,Mimbres,NM) Mitchell, John V. (A05) 1849-1925; 76 yrs (SJP) John V. and Martha Mitchell-parents of Mary Eddleman, wife of Mosby E. Eddleman-lnfo from Mary Eddleman of Bayard. Mitchell, Martha (A06) 1865-1919; 54 yrs (SJP) John V. and Martha Mitchell-parents of Mary Eddleman, wife of Mosby E. Eddleman-lnfo from Mary Eddleman of Bayard. Montoya, Bersabe (C06)06/28/1901-12/18/19l6;14yrs,5mo,4da "HijalegitimaDonaciano [yjMariaE Montoya; Sehaidoperonoolvidado" (JSL) -03/1 8/1915 Montoya, Estaquio E. (COS) 09/12/1895-10/16/1916; 21 yrs, 1 mo,4da "HijodeDonaciano [y] Maria Montoya; sehaidoperono olvidado" Montoya, Lequira 1807-04/01/1927 (JSL) ?"*age 120 yr*", b. NM. h (Thomas) List shows G'twn Cem, City Mimbres Montoya, Seberito (C09)11/16/1907-12/17/1916;9yrs,1mo,1da "Hijo de Donaciano [y] Maria Montoya" More, Charles 1807-10/1876; 69 yrs (JSL) OB-QCH Nicolai, Carlos (D01) 07/1834-09/26/1882; 48yrs,2mo Olguin, Rafaria 1856-08/18/1921; 65 yrs (JSL) ?b. Mex, f. (7-Valenzuela. b. Mex), m. (Conception Celaya, b. Mex)., w. Syenino Poe, Allan (JSL)& (SJP) Poe, Jim (JSL)& (SJP) Poe, Rose (JSL)& Powers, John -02/24/1880 (JSL) OB-GCH Putney, (A09) (SJP) Putney, Mrs. (A08) (JSL)& (SJP)graves of Mrs. Putney and her stillborn daughters. This info from Mrs. Car/Dodson (her sister) of Hurley, NM. Putney (A09a and b) (JSL)& (Daughter) {SJP)graves of Mrs. Putney and her stillborn daughters. This info from Mrs. Cary Dodson (her sister) of Hurley, NM. Raffarty, -03/1877 (JSL) OB-QCH Romero, Maria Madrid 05/1891 -11/24/1928; 37 yrs, 6 mos (JSL) Roundtree, Francis M. (815)07/27/1920- 'Papa' Roundtree, Kitty Mae(Bl6)06/24/1920-01/24/1998;77yrs,7mos G.G. Ryan, Michael 1853-5/10/1879 (JSL) OB-GCH Sible, G. B. (C21) -1886 (JSL) Sibole; Shoemaker (SJP) Mrs. Maude Bagwell stated that Mr. Sibole was her father's partner. Smith, Bertha (805) 09/03/1882-10/1882; Imo "Born ofG.O. & E.B. Smith" Smith, Harold M. (A16) 10/31/1914- Smith, Jewell A. (Al7)07/04/1915-02/27/1997;81yrs,7mos,13da Smith, Shirley Ann (A18) 03/10/1945- "Mama" Spiller, Annie (B10)07/1882-10/31/1890;8yrs,3mo (SJP) "Children of Mr. & Mrs. John Spiller" Spiller, Freddie (B09) 10/1886-05/19/1890;3yrs,7mo (SJP) "Children of Mr. & Mrs. John Spiller" Storz, John Martin. (AH) 10/24/1842-03/22/1929; 86yrs,4mo,26da "Father" Storz, Sophie (A10)02/28/1871-08/03/1898;27yrs,5mos,3da "Mother Sacred to the memory of Suvia, Petronilia (C16) 1864-06/18/1929; 65 yrs stone badly broken (JSL) & "MurioDia 18 de 1929, Junion a la eda 65 anos" Thompson, Moreno de,Dona Casimira (D02) 1844-12/12/1880;36yrs (JSL) & "Murio el dia 12 decbre de 1880 36 anos de edad" Trugio, Tiodoso (C15) long, narrow limestone w/ cross and name only Venavides, Roberto (C01)04/20/1903-12/22/1915;12yrs,8mos,2da "Hijo de U. [y] de P.S. de Venavides/se ha ido pero no olivadado" Georgetown New Mexico Dorothy M. Wokee Grant County was not overlooked in the westward movement that took place between the end of the Civil War and the beginning of World War I. In his book, Ghost Towns of New Mexico. Michael Jenkinson says that during the emigration a number of people came into southwestern New Mexico "They were ...drawn by publicity of promoters; mesmerized by brochures such as the one which portrayed paddle-wheelers heaped high with cotton plying the Mimbres River. Few found the land as easy as they expected. It was a country of contrasts, stony deserts and high humped ranges....The Mimbres, they discovered, was a shallow, placid stream that most of the year would not support a good-sized raft". Nestled in one of these humped ranges was the mining camp of Georgetown which did the most to earn for Grant County the tide of the "Treasure Vault of New Mexico". This contribution was largely unrecognized since Silver City was credited for much of the bullion shipped from Georgetown. Most of the silver chloride ore was relatively close to the ground and could be reached by a network of extensive underground tunnels. The deepest shaft, the Naiad Queen was only 600 feet deep. Although silver was discovered in the Georgetown area in 1866, the town was not developed until 1872. That year marked the arrival of John and George Magruder from Georgetown, DC, who had tried their hand at ranching and as merchants before being struck by the prospecting fever. George was "killed at Mimbres Reduction Works" according to his obituary in the Grant County Herald, on April 5, 1877, and although buried in Mimbres, NM, no cemetery was named. John named the town in honor of both his birthplace and his brother. Taking a wagon trail East from Fort Bayard through a range of unsurpassed beauty, the traveler would reach Georgetown gulch at the base of the Parapet Mountain. After having seen the raw diggings of other camps, newcomers were surprised at the advancing development in this mining camp. By 1875 the camp was thriving. While pleasant, progressive surroundings and the promise of comparatively rapid financial gain enticed many people, others came for security from Indian raids which were disrupting nearby camps. Miners from the Hillsboro placer mines escaped across the Black Range to Georgetown where the citizens supplied Fort Craig and their own Ojo Calieme outpost with provisions in exchange for protection. In 1880 Georgetown had a population of 54 people; in 1883, 800; by 1888 it was a community with 1,200 residents. Stereotypical images of a haphazardly constructed mining camp never applied to Georgetown. Careful planning organized the town in the shape of a "V" around a spring which provided a water source for the entire community. At the north end was the "better residential district" along with the church and school; the commercial area was located in the center; and at the south end were the miners quarters, the town jail, the cemetery and the homes of shady and questionable characters. All of the structures were made of adobe and many were two stories; some had fronts of wood construction. Stability and industry are further demonstrated by the number and variety of business and social ventures: 2 sawmills, and a lumber yard; a boot and shoemaker; town carpenter; blacksmith; wagonmaker; town physician; hospital; drugstore; bakery; meat market; four or five dry goods stores; 2 restaurants; brewery; billiard parlor; 20 saloons; hotel and skating rink. The townspeople also organized entertainment such as horse racing, picnics, basket suppers, socials, literary clubs and dramatic societies. For those who wanted to visit elsewhere, there was each day a stage line to and from Silver City and for those who preferred to ride alone a livery service was available. In 1891, there was even passenger train service provided by the Arizona-New Mexico Railroad to Georgetown. News from the outside was delivered through the newsstand and the postmaster. In the summer of 1881 the town started its own newspaper, the Silver Times (later the name was changed to Georgetown Courier). Education was not neglected as Georgetown was credited for erecting the first free public school building in the Territory; before long the town had both an upper and lower grade school. Of course, this was a mining town and, therefore, in need of some lively nighttime diversion. This, it provided in ample supply. After a hard days labor a man was hard pressed to find a seat in one of the camps many saloons each of which had two or more gambling tables which operated around the clock. Chairs at the game tables were never empty and fortunes won from the earth were lost in a single turn of a card. Would any tale of a Grant County town during this era be complete without mention of Billy the Kid? Tentative agreement exists that Bill's step-father, William Antrim, ran a restaurant in Georgetown and the boy played in the dusty streets of the camp as a child. Some accounts suggest that the Kid later returned to the town where he was fortified with food and clothing by Mrs. Magruder, wife of the founder, and found safety at times by hiding in the town's cemetery. Despite the occasional concession to its Wild West setting and season, Georgetown was reputed for its uniqueness among mining towns as being peaceful and agreeable. An old-timer wrote the following to the Las Vegas Eureka in November 1879:
For the better part of three decades Georgetown prospered as a community, but by 1903 the population had dwindled to a mere one hundred. With a population high of 1200 during this period, slightly over 3% (39) were buried in the town's cemetery. Thirty-six percent of these were 16 years of age or under when they died; and 41% for whom age at time of death is unknown. Historians attribute the decline of Georgetown to
one, or a combination of three factors: 2) A fire. Even today many local people believe a voracious fire caused the end of Georgetown. However, Edward Rosenfeld in his New Mexico Magazine article "The Silver Boom at Georgetown" provides an eyewitness account of the limitations of the fire. He watched the onset of the fire burn the company store and spread to the "Chinese restaurant and the butcher shop" before it was "finally checked". Those wooden storefronts were backed by adobe walls which, no doubt, retarded the spread. 3) Economics. In 1893 Congress passed a law which demonetized silver causing silver values to drop below a dollar an ounce. This is the most repeated and most likely cause of the town's demise. Whatever may have caused the extinction of Georgetown a century ago is of little concern to the lone resident today (this author) who is included to agree with F. Stanley when he said that the real secrets of places like Georgetown "...Are her beautiful hills, scenic mountains...arroyos, brilliant sun, a sky that matches Mary's mantle, vigorous winters, (and) a silence that even grasshoppers respect." Today, foundations are barely visible throughout the town site. Many ranch houses and barns in the Mimbres valley are constructed with adobe bricks from Georgetown. Silver prices still inhibit mining activity. During the summer months tourists dot the hills with their metal detectors looking for tokens from the stage line, leaving with a handful of square nails, blissfully unaware that the stage used wooden tokens. In the fall of some years local residents converge upon the site to harvest the area's bounty again; this time it was Pinon nuts. Interestingly, the favorite and most productive spot for this harvest is around the cemetery. It is almost as if the former residents assist nature in the production of the crop in order to occasionally witness the kind of activity that once was representative of their town.
Georgetown Cemetery Data Base
Added by Randy
Sweeten: ©2005 |